Opinion 
 Blogs 
 National Comment 
 A bit of maturity from those who have it would be nice 

A bit of maturity from those who have it would be nice

IT'S touching how many people are concerned for the welfare of Ms X. Sam Gilbert, St Kilda Football Club, the AFL, media, Derryn Hinch: all on her case, and without a thought for themselves. The latest is Ricky Nixon, so very touching.

The central issue is personal responsibility. All the adults in this weird saga are old enough to know what they are doing. She, despite appearances, and no matter how much she thinks she is, isn't - not in the shark pool in which she finds herself.

Part of her predicament is that her story is playing out in social media, a forum whose boundaries aren't established. Certainly, old media boundaries - defamation, taste, protection of innocents - do not exist. It means the story moves at breakneck speed, out of anyone's control, and often leaps ahead of itself.

It also means that a teenager, legally a minor, is leading the AFL a merry dance, even as she is led on one. Ideally for her - for the welfare all profess to have at heart - there would now be a moratorium. During it, competent authorities could deal with her and the AFL would deal with Nixon. Severely. But it won't happen.

It is also touching how many people are concerned for the welfare of Brendan Fevola. The Brisbane Lions remained concerned yesterday, even as they sacked him. That's tough love.

The difference between Ms X and Fevola is that he is 30, and has had plenty of time to grow up, and plenty of guidance - more than most troubled and troublesome teenagers get.

Carlton gave up on him and now Brisbane has, too. The timing is strange, but the decision is not. Football clubs are as responsible as all organisations for their people's welfare, but they are not welfare agencies. Their job is to win games. That does not excuse a lack of compassion, but it does not constrain them to act as charities.

Ultimately, a footballer has to take responsibility for his own actions, his own life. Peter Costello's populist posturing notwithstanding, most do. Now would be a good time for Fevola to start.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size




RELATED COVERAGE

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Let's be honest. Ms X needs some SERIOUS psychological help. I don't mean that in a derogitory fashion, but the fact is, she's seems to be screaming for attention. Her lies regarding the photo involving naked players was found out when the hotel the players were in was identified, in Miami. She set it up. Nixon should have known is was dangerous to have anything to do with her. Regardless of wether it was a set up or not, Nixon has to take a good hard look at himself. Nixon's actions, wether innocent or not, have brought the game into question again. And let's not forget, this is not Nixon's first indiscretion.
Posted by Jazzy, 22/02/2011 8:58:14 AM
Im glad its happened. It draws attention to the biff, drunken, sexually immoral culture that football is.

It needs to be cleaned up and moral standards brought back in:)

Posted by GGibson, 22/02/2011 10:58:15 AM
Football, meat pies and Holden cars. So whats new!
Posted by Bush Bunny, 22/02/2011 11:34:43 AM
there is no fool like an old fool how sickening this man must be brain dead blind freddy would have seen where this was heading
Posted by charlotte, 22/02/2011 2:18:26 PM
Something awful happened to this girl and no-one is helping her to recover.

St Kilda are definitely covering up something very sinister.

Why else would they put "resources" in place for her. Footballers are not Gods. Football culture is all about the "boys", women are only ever there to be used and abused, as we see often. Heroes? Role models? not a chance, and the women get the bad press.

Remember the "Team" incident by the Bulldogs? All codes are a disgrace.

Shame on St Kilda, shame on the AFL...

Go Pies !!!

Posted by Tacklerat, 23/02/2011 9:29:50 AM
Who are these people to warrant any attention whatsoever? I thought that the circus had concluded with the departure of Liz Hurley.
Posted by Cheeba's Mum, 24/02/2011 1:20:16 PM
National Comment
Here is the place for you to vent on any national or world news and lifestyle stories on the YourGuide websites. If there is anything you see or hear that you like or don't like, tell us. Don't keep it to yourself!
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
POLL
Q: Should player manager Ricky Nixon lose his accreditation over allegations of inappropriate dealings with the teen at the centre of the St Kilda nude photos scandal?

Yes
(79.2%)

No
(20.8%)

Total Votes: 3794
Poll Date: 22 February, 2011

Most popular articles




The Ridge News







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...